Rashi and Tosafot: The Classic Commentaries on the Daf
Rashi and Tosafot are the two commentaries printed beside the Gemara on almost every daf of the Talmud Bavli. Rashi explains the text line by line so the learner can understand it; Tosafot step back and ask questions, comparing the sugya with other places in Shas and with Rashi’s explanation. In the standard Vilna layout, Rashi sits on the inner column of the page, near the binding, and Tosafot on the outer column.
Who was Rashi?
Rashi (רש”י) is the acronym of Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki, who lived in Troyes, France, from 1040 to 1105. He wrote a commentary on the Torah and most of Tanach, and a commentary on nearly the entire Talmud Bavli. Both are still the first commentaries most learners open.
Rashi’s commentary on the Gemara is short and precise. He explains difficult words — sometimes translating them into the French of his day — fills in the steps of an argument that the Gemara leaves unstated, identifies who is asking and who is answering, and clarifies which reading of the text he follows. A learner who reads the Gemara together with Rashi can usually follow the simple meaning of the sugya.
On a few parts of Shas, the commentary printed in Rashi’s place was written or completed by others. The best-known example is Bava Batra, where most of the commentary is by Rashbam, Rashi’s grandson.
What are Tosafot?
Tosafot (תוספות, “additions”) are not the work of a single author. They are the collected comments of the Ba’alei HaTosafot, the Talmudic scholars of France and Germany from the 12th through the 14th centuries. Many of them were Rashi’s descendants and students; among the most prominent was Rabbeinu Tam, Rashi’s grandson.
The Tosafot are “additions” to Rashi in the sense that they build on his work. Their typical method is to raise a difficulty: a statement in this sugya appears to contradict a Gemara elsewhere in Shas, or Rashi’s explanation seems hard to reconcile with another source. They then propose a resolution, often drawing a fine distinction. In doing so they treat the whole Talmud as one connected body of knowledge, and many of their comments have become the basis of later halachic discussion.
Rashi and Tosafot compared
| Rashi | Tosafot | |
|---|---|---|
| Author | Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki (1040–1105) | The Ba’alei HaTosafot, 12th–14th centuries |
| Where | Troyes, France | France and Germany |
| Place on the daf | Inner column | Outer column |
| Main goal | Explain the simple meaning of the text | Analyze, compare and resolve difficulties |
| Scope of a comment | Usually the line in front of you | Often the whole of Shas |
Where they sit on the page
The layout of the Vilna Shas, printed by the Romm press in Vilna in the 1880s, has become the standard for the daf. The Gemara text is in the center. Rashi runs alongside it in the column closest to the binding, and Tosafot in the column toward the outer edge of the page. Both are printed in a semi-cursive typeface known as “Rashi script,” which is used for many commentaries; the name comes from the fact that it was used to print his commentary, not from his own handwriting. Each comment opens with a dibbur hamatchil — the opening words of the passage in the Gemara it explains — so you can match the comment to the line. For a full tour of the page, see What is a daf?
How to use them when learning Daf Yomi
Learners use the commentaries in different ways, and there is no single correct method. Some common approaches:
- Gemara with Rashi. Many Daf Yomi learners read Rashi on every line or on every difficult line. This is often enough to understand the flow of the sugya.
- Selected Tosafot. Some add a Tosafot or two on each daf — often the one that addresses the central question of the sugya.
- Review with Tosafot. Others first learn the daf with Rashi, then go back to Tosafot when reviewing, once the basic structure is clear.
A shiur that explains the daf with Rashi’s interpretation, and points out where Tosafot add or disagree, is a practical way to get the benefit of both. For more on working through a passage step by step, see how to follow a sugya.
Frequently asked questions
What does “Rashi” stand for?
It is an acronym of Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki, the commentator who lived in Troyes, France, 1040–1105.
Is Tosafot one person?
No. Tosafot are the collected comments of many scholars, the Ba’alei HaTosafot of France and Germany, from the 12th to 14th centuries.
Which side of the page is Rashi on?
The inner column, near the binding. Tosafot are on the outer column.
Do I need Tosafot to learn Daf Yomi?
Many learners cover the daf with Gemara and Rashi alone and add Tosafot as time allows. Choose a pace you can keep up; see how to learn Daf Yomi.
Listen to the shiurim
The Daf Yomi shiurim on MyShiur go through each daf in order, beginning with Masechet Berachot, and are a helpful companion when learning Gemara with Rashi and Tosafot. They are given in Hebrew by Rav Yehuda Eliyahu and are free to stream or download as MP3. Choose any masechta, such as Bava Batra or Chullin, and start listening.